Comic Books > Mystery Tales

Mystery Tales Prices & Mystery Tales Value Guide

Mystery Tales Issue list & price guide. Prices for all 57 Mystery Tales Issues.

Prices are updated daily based upon Mystery Tales listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. Read our methodology.

Shortcuts: Most Expensive, Cheapest, List by Release Date

PriceCharting Index: Mystery Tales

Average 'raw' issue value (excludes variants) for Mystery Tales (details)

Sort & Filter +

You can filter lists by issue number.

You can change the sort order too. This will be remembered as your default for future visits.
Ok

Issue	Raw	6.0 / Fine	8.0 / VF
Mystery Tales #1 (1952)	$252.46	$1,345.65	$3,308.82	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #10 (1953)	$76.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #11 (1953)	$420.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #12 (1953)				+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #13 (1953)	$77.67			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #14 (1953)	$131.45		$2,280.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #15 (1953)	$345.89	$550.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #16 (1964)	$13.68			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #16 (1953)	$36.99			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #17 (1954)	$99.00	$775.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #18 (1954)	$99.99	$498.81	$1,178.94	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #19 (1954)			$14,400.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #2 (1952)	$135.50	$719.82	$1,762.72	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #20 (1954)	$157.98			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #21 (1954)	$110.70			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #22 (1954)	$197.50	$960.01	$2,245.38	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #23 (1954)	$51.75			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #24 (1954)	$117.50	$213.07		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #25 (1955)		$275.00	$330.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #26 (1955)			$161.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #27 (1955)	$76.00	$156.98	$188.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #28 (1955)	$132.25	$216.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #29 (1955)	$58.00	$174.01		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #3 (1952)	$85.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #30 (1955)	$110.50			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #31 (1955)	$28.99	$225.00	$324.85	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #32 (1955)	$42.48	$204.39	$469.37	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #33 (1955)	$76.05	$312.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #34 (1955)	$26.28	$124.27	$291.37	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #35 (1955)	$100.99	$474.74	$1,086.99	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #36 (1955)	$20.50			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #37 (1956)	$71.29	$334.61	$763.30	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #39 (1956)	$27.99			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #4 (1952)			$1,920.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #40 (1956)	$227.50			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #41 (1956)	$33.02			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #42 (1956)	$41.00	$191.70	$433.23	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #43 (1956)	$47.52			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #44 (1956)	$60.45	$281.69	$635.23	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #45 (1956)	$41.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #46 (1956)	$39.99			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #47 (1956)	$26.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #48 (1956)	$37.52			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #49 (1957)	$31.57	$386.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #5 (1952)	$48.56			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #50 (1957)	$112.50			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #51 (1957)	$39.00		$384.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #52 (1957)	$57.52	$234.98	$240.80	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #53 (1957)	$44.00	$279.99	$441.84	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #54 (1957)	$28.57	$128.80	$284.48	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist