Comic Books > Mystery Tales

Most Expensive Mystery Tales Comic Books

Most Expensive Mystery Tales Issue list & price guide. Prices for all 57 Mystery Tales Issues.

Prices are updated daily based upon Mystery Tales listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. Read our methodology.

Shortcuts: Most Expensive, Cheapest, Most Popular Issues

You own: 0 / 57 items 0% Track your collection for free

PriceCharting Index: Mystery Tales

Average 'raw' issue value (excludes variants) for Mystery Tales | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

Sort & Filter +

Sort by

Release Date

Issue Number

Variants

Images

Collection

You can filter lists by issue number.

You can change the sort order too. This will be remembered as your default for future visits.
Ok

Issue	Ungraded ▼	6.0	8.0
Mystery Tales #19 (1954)	$911.00		$14,400.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #1 (1952)	$340.47			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #2 (1952)	$285.00	$541.29		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #40 (1956)	$243.75			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #15 (1953)	$217.75	$550.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #24 (1954)	$216.03	$208.20		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #8 (1953)	$197.27			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #17 (1954)	$186.38	$775.00	$2,640.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #5 (1952)	$182.45			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #7 (1953)	$172.13			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #12 (1953)	$161.22		$1,900.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #9 (1953)	$150.49			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #22 (1954)	$147.68		$688.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #10 (1953)	$137.50		$1,300.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #14 (1953)	$131.45		$2,280.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #38 (1956)	$120.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #27 (1955)	$115.04	$260.00	$312.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #16 (1953)	$108.00	$200.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #11 (1953)	$104.70			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #26 (1955)	$103.50	$534.83	$730.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #20 (1954)	$100.00	$384.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #43 (1956)	$91.00	$360.44		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #48 (1956)	$90.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #23 (1954)	$89.16			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #3 (1952)	$85.10			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #6 (1952)	$83.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #21 (1954)	$82.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #34 (1955)	$74.38	$257.69		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #25 (1955)	$72.00	$228.50	$274.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #47 (1956)	$70.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #4 (1952)	$69.03		$1,920.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #18 (1954)	$67.02			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #53 (1957)	$64.99	$199.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #45 (1956)	$64.63	$264.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #41 (1956)	$63.90			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #35 (1955)	$63.73			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #36 (1955)	$63.00	$184.41		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #39 (1956)	$62.00			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #13 (1953)	$61.33	$475.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #46 (1956)	$61.03			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #52 (1957)	$51.00		$446.16	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #28 (1955)	$50.00	$216.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #49 (1957)	$50.00	$386.00	$1,320.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #44 (1956)	$49.60			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #30 (1955)	$45.50	$186.36		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #33 (1955)	$44.99	$312.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #51 (1957)	$44.99		$384.00	+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #50 (1957)	$44.68			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #37 (1956)	$40.14			+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist
Mystery Tales #31 (1955)	$39.38	$225.00		+ Collection In One Click + Collection With Details + Wishlist + Collection + Wishlist