Indian Head Penny Prices & Indian Cent Value Guide

Indian Head Penny Coin list & price guide. Prices for all 162 Indian Cent Coins.

Prices are updated based upon Indian Head Penny listings that sold on eBay and other marketplaces.

Shortcuts: Most Popular Coins, Most Expensive, Cheapest

You own: 0 / 162 items 0% Track your collection for free

PriceCharting Index: Indian Head Penny

Average ungraded coin value for Indian Head Penny | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

  US Coins Ungraded MS62 MS66
1858 [PROOF]
  • + Wishlist
1859 $19.34 $614.00 $11,032.38
  • + Wishlist
1859 [DOUBLE DIE] $142.50
  • + Wishlist
1859 [PROOF] $577.43 $9,171.07
  • + Wishlist
1860 $17.10 $380.50 $3,720.00
  • + Wishlist
1860 [PROOF] $359.00 $7,561.93
  • + Wishlist
1861 $28.75 $313.49 $4,122.29
  • + Wishlist
1861 [PROOF] $27.50 $27,937.50
  • + Wishlist
1862 $10.35 $252.21 $2,233.36
  • + Wishlist
1862 [PROOF] $17.60 $3,360.00
  • + Wishlist
1862 [TYPE 3] $379.38 $665.00
  • + Wishlist
1863 $9.23 $233.51 $3,720.00
  • + Wishlist
1863 [FS-302]
  • + Wishlist
1863 [PROOF] $277.25 $9,140.39
  • + Wishlist
1864 $12.75 $258.41 $3,696.20
  • + Wishlist
1864 L [DOUBLE DIE] $182.50
  • + Wishlist
1864 [BRONZE PROOF] $3,937.33 $28,721.30
  • + Wishlist
1864 [BRONZE TYPE 3] $174.68
  • + Wishlist
1864 [BRONZE] $16.50 $180.73 $1,396.11
  • + Wishlist
1864 [COPPER PROOF] $1,362.49 $6,755.50
  • + Wishlist
1864 [COPPER] $15.68 $317.50 $6,078.32
  • + Wishlist
1864 [DOUBLE DIE FS-1101 $543.31
  • + Wishlist
1864 [L FS-2301] $203.83
  • + Wishlist
1864 [L FS-2302] $250.00
  • + Wishlist
1864 [L PROOF]
  • + Wishlist
1864 [L] $47.31 $387.04 $10,163.75
  • + Wishlist
1865 $7.69 $201.75 $15,435.00
  • + Wishlist
1865 [DOUBLE DIE FS-1801] $225.00
  • + Wishlist
1865 [DOUBLE DIE] $61.56
  • + Wishlist
1865 [FS-303] $97.50
  • + Wishlist
1865 [FS-304]
  • + Wishlist
1865 [PROOF] $566.99 $9,070.17
  • + Wishlist
1866 $25.12 $499.00 $13,390.71
  • + Wishlist
1866 [DOUBLE DIE] $240.00
  • + Wishlist
1866 [FS-301] $63.33 $485.00 $12,247.48
  • + Wishlist
1866 [PROOF] $620.36 $13,783.51
  • + Wishlist
1867 $31.17 $425.07 $13,110.41
  • + Wishlist
1867 [FS-301] $171.60 $2,642.75 $33,055.40
  • + Wishlist
1867 [PROOF] $752.83 $7,140.00
  • + Wishlist
1868 $20.62 $429.28 $12,120.00
  • + Wishlist
1868 [DOUBLE DIE FS-101]
  • + Wishlist
1868 [PROOF] $570.00 $6,966.84
  • + Wishlist
1869 $56.45 $857.25 $23,205.03
  • + Wishlist
1869 [PROOF] $1,250.00 $9,784.38
  • + Wishlist
1870 $38.50 $716.36 $7,633.39
  • + Wishlist
1870 [DOUBLE DIE FS-101]
  • + Wishlist
1870 [DOUBLE DIE] $181.13 $460.00 $33,394.74
  • + Wishlist
1870 [FS-301] $298.00
  • + Wishlist
1870 [FS-901] $249.00 $16,200.00
  • + Wishlist
1870 [PROOF] $1,209.74 $8,240.50
  • + Wishlist

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a Pokemon/Magic Card or Comic photo. Find the best match in our database


Best Matches