Indian Head Penny Prices & Indian Cent Value Guide

Indian Head Penny Coin list & price guide. Prices for all 118 Indian Cent Coins.

Prices are updated daily based upon Indian Head Penny listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. Read our methodology.

Shortcuts: Most Expensive, Cheapest, Most Popular Coins

You own: 0 / 118 items 0% Track your collection for free

PriceCharting Index: Indian Head Penny

Average ungraded coin value for Indian Head Penny | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

Sort & Filter +

Sort by

Variants/Proofs

Year Minted




You can change the sort order. This will be remembered as your default for future visits.
Ok
  US Coins Ungraded MS62 MS66
1859 $16.06 $578.39 $15,532.38
  • + Wishlist
1859 [PROOF] $9,400.00
  • + Wishlist
1860 $12.75 $297.43 $7,602.50
  • + Wishlist
1860 [PROOF] $9,091.49
  • + Wishlist
1861 $29.50 $283.25 $3,030.00
  • + Wishlist
1861 [PROOF] $17,529.36
  • + Wishlist
1862 $18.82 $212.17 $2,381.25
  • + Wishlist
1862 [PROOF] $2,026.01 $9,764.81
  • + Wishlist
1863 $14.85 $212.32 $3,400.80
  • + Wishlist
1863 [PROOF] $19,950.00
  • + Wishlist
1864 $8.52 $320.01 $4,187.68
  • + Wishlist
1864 [BRONZE PROOF] $1,525.50 $14,758.33
  • + Wishlist
1864 [BRONZE] $13.50 $181.15 $1,476.94
  • + Wishlist
1864 [COPPER PROOF] $9,175.12
  • + Wishlist
1864 [COPPER] $20.63 $256.55 $8,912.50
  • + Wishlist
1864 [L PROOF]
  • + Wishlist
1864 [L] $38.93 $609.58 $12,021.88
  • + Wishlist
1865 $11.58 $240.63 $11,747.00
  • + Wishlist
1865 [PROOF] $12,588.22
  • + Wishlist
1866 $24.42 $387.35 $9,094.53
  • + Wishlist
1866 [PROOF] $17,618.38
  • + Wishlist
1867 $22.95 $415.00 $14,961.14
  • + Wishlist
1867 [FS-301] $72.50 $2,000.00 $13,559.68
  • + Wishlist
1867 [PROOF] $925.50 $12,017.50
  • + Wishlist
1868 $19.49 $388.13 $10,468.67
  • + Wishlist
1868 [PROOF] $762.00 $15,044.04
  • + Wishlist
1869 $41.69 $1,188.00 $24,463.73
  • + Wishlist
1869 [PROOF] $851.00 $10,814.41
  • + Wishlist
1870 $44.02 $749.86 $14,658.40
  • + Wishlist
1870 [PROOF] $955.00 $3,558.51
  • + Wishlist
1871 $59.50 $720.00 $32,400.00
  • + Wishlist
1871 [PROOF] $1,768.89 $8,134.24
  • + Wishlist
1872 $75.84 $758.25 $38,755.40
  • + Wishlist
1872 [PROOF] $1,437.82 $7,154.84
  • + Wishlist
1873 $12.25 $364.12 $15,438.47
  • + Wishlist
1873 [CLOSED 3 PROOF] $10,745.16
  • + Wishlist
1873 [CLOSED 3] $17.29 $544.41 $31,200.00
  • + Wishlist
1873 [DOUBLE LIBERTY] $511.00 $11,271.39 $123,477.86
  • + Wishlist
1873 [PROOF] $300.00 $19,200.00
  • + Wishlist
1874 $9.28 $248.05 $8,485.05
  • + Wishlist
1874 [PROOF] $636.00 $9,745.27
  • + Wishlist
1875 $9.53 $250.00 $5,729.36
  • + Wishlist
1875 [PROOF] $960.00 $27,600.00
  • + Wishlist
1876 $20.50 $345.00 $9,026.79
  • + Wishlist
1876 [PROOF] $700.00 $11,775.38
  • + Wishlist
1877 $477.00 $6,260.00 $58,599.46
  • + Wishlist
1877 [PROOF] $3,050.14 $16,503.57
  • + Wishlist
1878 $19.74 $350.00 $11,400.00
  • + Wishlist
1878 [PROOF] $285.00 $8,143.05
  • + Wishlist
1879 $6.83 $143.50 $10,248.38
  • + Wishlist

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a Pokemon Card or Comic photo. Find the best match in our database


Best Matches