Search

Comic Books > Nightmare

Nightmare Prices & Nightmare Value Guide

Nightmare Issue list & price guide. Prices for all 34 Nightmare Issues.

Prices are updated based upon Nightmare listings that sold on eBay and other marketplaces.

Shortcuts: Most Popular Issues, Most Expensive, Cheapest

You own: 0 / 34 items 0% Track your collection for free

PriceCharting Index: Nightmare

Average 'raw' issue value (excludes variants) for Nightmare | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

  Issue Ungraded 6.0 8.0
Nightmare #1 (1952) $123.53 $536.19 $1,821.14
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #2 (1952) $92.19 $264.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #3 (1953) $50.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #10 (1953) $95.83
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #11 (1954) $111.08
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #12 (1954) $115.00 $238.49 $525.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #13 (1954) $190.50 $1,790.59
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #1 (1970) $59.28
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #2 (1971) $41.23
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #3 (1971) $18.99 $61.43 $111.88
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #4 (1971) $23.45 $74.29 $147.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #5 (1971) $14.96
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #6 (1971) $15.93 $189.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #7 (1972) $19.74 $60.39 $149.95
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #8 (1972) $15.00 $47.50 $84.80
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #9 (1972) $27.03 $81.17 $143.59
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #10 (1972) $15.31 $48.83 $86.64
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #11 (1973) $20.02 $60.95 $107.52
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #12 (1973) $10.15
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #13 (1973) $19.01 $67.99 $119.10
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #14 (1973) $12.44
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #15 (1973) $15.81 $375.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #16 (1973) $18.99 $56.28 $97.97
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #17 (1974) $27.65 $80.07 $138.34
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #18 (1974) $43.96
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #19 (1974) $21.91 $67.41 $123.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #20 (1974) $91.21 $245.33 $416.98
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #21 (1974) $18.50 $53.49 $91.86
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #22 (1974) $8.00
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #23 (1975) $28.89
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #1 (1994) $16.40 $24.01 $31.79
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #2 (1995) $1.88
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #3 (1995) $2.42
  • + Wishlist
Nightmare #4 (1995) $7.15
  • + Wishlist

PriceCharting © 2007-2025
We are user supported. We may earn an affiliate commission if you buy stuff after clicking links on our site to eBay or Amazon

PriceIt Game | No More Secrets Puzzle Game

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a Pokemon/Magic Card or Comic photo. Find the best match in our database


Best Matches