Buffalo Nickel Checklist: All Coins

Buffalo Nickel Coin list & price guide. Prices for all 93 Buffalo Five Cents Coins.

Prices are updated based upon Buffalo Nickel listings that sold on eBay and other marketplaces.

Shortcuts: Most Popular Coins, Most Expensive, Cheapest

You own: 0 / 93 items 0% Track your collection for free

PriceCharting Index: Buffalo Nickel

Average ungraded coin value for Buffalo Nickel | Compare vs.

Premium: Download Price List

More Filters ⮟
  US Coins Ungraded MS62 MS66
1937 D [3 LEGS] $748.80 $3,411.78 $45,700.00
  • + Wishlist
1936 $8.33 $38.94 $133.65
  • + Wishlist
1916 [PROOF] $17.15
  • + Wishlist
1935 $10.02 $37.87 $205.52
  • + Wishlist
1913 [TYPE 2 PROOF] $1,461.00 $3,025.23
  • + Wishlist
1936 [BRILLIANT PROOF] $469.68 $1,559.94
  • + Wishlist
1936 D $10.47 $45.00 $164.99
  • + Wishlist
1936 S $7.41 $41.48 $216.79
  • + Wishlist
1913 S [TYPE 1 NO F]
  • + Wishlist
1913 [TYPE 1 PROOF] $122.50 $3,252.00
  • + Wishlist
1926 $17.01 $80.80 $454.69
  • + Wishlist
1929 $6.99 $64.54 $819.00
  • + Wishlist
1935 D $15.42 $67.19 $765.88
  • + Wishlist
1913 [TYPE 2] $27.99 $87.50 $678.73
  • + Wishlist
1918/7 D $814.01 $28,773.00 $244,475.00
  • + Wishlist
1937 [PROOF] $1,647.19 $1,400.00
  • + Wishlist
1913 D [TYPE 1] $24.75 $119.00 $999.34
  • + Wishlist
1913 D [TYPE 2] $65.99 $273.75 $7,162.72
  • + Wishlist
1913 [TYPE 1] $15.93 $68.38 $416.10
  • + Wishlist
1914 $19.99 $111.30 $1,158.75
  • + Wishlist
1925 $3.75 $105.76 $858.75
  • + Wishlist
1937 $5.75 $29.07 $80.00
  • + Wishlist
1938 D/D $15.00 $24.50 $101.98
  • + Wishlist
1913 S [TYPE 1] $44.10 $199.99 $1,498.50
  • + Wishlist
1914 D $73.12 $500.00 $2,640.00
  • + Wishlist
1914 S $21.59 $241.00 $5,400.00
  • + Wishlist
1914 [PROOF] $1,237.01 $2,402.53
  • + Wishlist
1915 $20.00 $89.99 $715.00
  • + Wishlist
1915 [PROOF] $1,280.00 $3,011.94
  • + Wishlist
1916 $15.13 $90.00 $810.00
  • + Wishlist
1916 D $21.51 $192.50 $11,454.60
  • + Wishlist
1916 S $22.53 $298.34 $5,280.00
  • + Wishlist
1916 [DOUBLED DIE] $1,200.00 $8,874.96 $115,420.40
  • + Wishlist
1917 $10.78 $136.75 $1,027.22
  • + Wishlist
1917 D $15.78 $650.00 $5,220.00
  • + Wishlist
1917 S $20.44 $1,107.09 $10,037.50
  • + Wishlist
1918 $5.76 $218.51 $2,505.00
  • + Wishlist
1918 D $10.52 $670.69 $8,700.00
  • + Wishlist
1918 S $13.13 $1,762.09 $26,172.74
  • + Wishlist
1918 [FS-401] $39.99
  • + Wishlist
1919 D $14.25 $1,261.54 $10,800.00
  • + Wishlist
1919 S $13.06 $1,062.37 $37,564.85
  • + Wishlist
1920 S [FS-401] $19.20
  • + Wishlist
1920 [FS-401] $81.00
  • + Wishlist
1921 $7.08 $349.88 $1,576.00
  • + Wishlist
1921 S $44.50 $1,214.69 $14,446.00
  • + Wishlist
1923 $9.50 $130.50 $1,196.07
  • + Wishlist
1923 S $13.77 $719.75 $15,875.00
  • + Wishlist
1923 [FS-401] $137.45
  • + Wishlist
1924 $6.19 $181.16 $1,679.28
  • + Wishlist

Sort By

Filters

FAQ | Login Don't Want Ads?

Take/Upload a Pokemon/Magic Card or Comic photo. Find the best match in our database


Best Matches